All PostsDiscussionsBlogsIdeasQuestions
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               
Discussions
eBay Community logo
  • Home
  • News & Updates
  • Buying & Selling
    • Buying
    • Selling
    • New to selling on eBay
    • Seller Tools
    • Shipping
    • Returns
    • eBay Advertising
    • Payments
    • Mobile Apps
  • Explore Categories
      • eBay Motors
      • Electronics
      • Collectibles & Art
      • Home & Garden
      • Clothing, Shoes & Accessories
      • Toys & Hobbies
      • Sporting Goods
      • Books, Movies & Music
      • Health & Beauty
      • Business & Industrial
      • Jewelry & Watches
      • Specialty Services
      • eBay Partner Network
      • Accessibility
      • eBay Developers Program
      • eBay Cafe
      • eBay Live
      • Community Mentors
    • Ask a Mentor
  • About
    • About the Community
    • Share Community Platform Feedback
    • Report eBay Technical Issues
    • About eBay
  • Community Events
    • Events
    • Seller Circle Hosts
    • Seller Circles
  • eBay Help
  • Locked

    Discussions in this board are limited to the original poster and Community Mentors

    • Buying & SellingChevronRightIcon
    • Ask a MentorChevronRightIcon
    Requests and Disputes Tab is empty
                     

    I have disputed two returns. Both were returned as "not working or defective." I uploaded pictures and links to a YouTube video proving that they work, and created the dispute. This was 10 days ago, I have yet to receive an email confirmation and my "Returns and Disputes" tab is empty. I called eBay on day 2 and they said to wait and it'll show up. Day 10 and nothing. 

     

    At first, I had a very I return rate being I didn't know I could dispute these. Now that I'm disputing them, I get nowhere with it. 

    farejarelistings
    farejarelistings
    1077View listings
    Posted 1 year ago·Last reply 1 year ago
                                           
             
    8 comments

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       
                   
    lady_madonna

    lady_madonna

    Mentor1 year ago
    *Volunteer Ebay Mentor*1039View listings

    @farejarelistings 

    If the buyer(s) chose a reason for the return that is valid under Ebay's Money Back Guarantee (ex: "not as described", 'defective", "damaged", etc.), your dispute will not be honored.

     

                                           
    farejarelistings

    farejarelistings

    OP1 year ago
    1077View listings

    Ok, but it's not valid. Which is why I disputed the reason for return and proved why it is not valid with photos and videos.

    That's the whole reason for disputing, because their reason for return was not valid. 

                                           
    rock.star

    rock.star

    ·1 year ago
    1080View listings

    EBay will not look at Photos or videos. 

    They will take the buyers word. 

                                           
    farejarelistings

    farejarelistings

    OP1 year ago
    1077View listings

    So as a seller, there's no winning ever. eBay will always take their insane cut. Crazy. 

                                           
    lady_madonna

    lady_madonna

    Mentor1 year ago
    *Volunteer Ebay Mentor*1039View listings
    @farejarelistings wrote:

    Ok, but it's not valid. Which is why I disputed the reason for return and proved why it is not valid with photos and videos.

    That's the whole reason for disputing, because their reason for return was not valid. 

    @farejarelistings 

    According to Ebay if the buyer chose a valid reason according to the Ebay MBG (not according to the seller), Ebay will always find in favor of the buyer unless the buyer returns an item that is used, altered or damaged.

                                           
    farejarelistings

    farejarelistings

    OP1 year ago
    1077View listings

    So it sounds like if the buyer is lying, the only way to change the reason for return is to lie as well and say it's altered or damaged. 

    So basically a buyer who doesn't want to pay for a return label can just lie on their return reason and I can't do a single thing about it. And on top of that, eBay will take 5% more if I have a high return rate for this. 

    Insanity 

                                           
    lady_madonna

    lady_madonna

    Mentor1 year ago
    *Volunteer Ebay Mentor*1039View listings
    @farejarelistings wrote:

    So it sounds like if the buyer is lying, the only way to change the reason for return is to lie as well and say it's altered or damaged. 

    So basically a buyer who doesn't want to pay for a return label can just lie on their return reason and I can't do a single thing about it. And on top of that, eBay will take 5% more if I have a high return rate for this. 

    Insanity 

    @farejarelistings 

    This might help you with future return requests:

    https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/managing-returns-refunds/handle-return-request-seller?id=4115

                                           
    farejarelistings

    farejarelistings

    OP1 year ago
    1077View listings

    I've read through that. It just appears that the buyer can do whatever they want.

    No mention in the about disputing the reason for return. 

                                           
                                                                                     
    •                                                              
    •                                                              
    •