Please help what can I do about this?
Summary: josephtiffee experienced a catastrophic engine failure due to what they believe was a manufacturer defect in a piston purchased from a large seller in China. They reported the issue, citing a warranty statement from the seller claiming to cover all costs if the fault was theirs, but they only offered a refund for the parts. mr_lincoln sympathized and discussed potential challenges, including proving the defect. Another participant advised against purchasing inexpensive parts from unfamiliar sources, to which josephtiffee acknowledged the advice with hindsight.
I purchased a piston and jug. I had my mechanic install it. It was all torqued and installed correctly, and it had a catastrophic failure in the pistons, wrist pin area, resulting in $1300 worth of parts being destroyed in my engine. And all they want to do is refund me for the piston and jug


What can be done about this
krazzykats
MentorAvoid purchasing inexpensive engine parts from unfamiliar manufacturers.
josephtiffee
OPYeah, hindsight’s 2020, huh? Thanks for your sound advice
mr_lincoln
MentorHi @josephtiffee
-Were they manufacturer's parts or after market?
-Sellers can only refund the money that you paid them.
-What type of engine was it? Automobile? 4 Wheeler?
-The $ 1,300 in parts you mentioned, did they include replacement parts for what the Seller sent you and if so where would they be coming from?
josephtiffee
OPI get what you’re saying, (sellers can only refund the money that you paid them) but that’s not entirely true, because they could easily pay for the parts that their part destroyed. Especially when their part that had a manufacturer’s defect. And on their page in the description of the part, it says, and I quote” We afford all cost if it's our fault”!!! It is a LTZ 400. That $1300 in parts is to buy the parts on eBay. such as a rebuild kit, a crank, a rod, a starter, two cases for the engine, because it broke both sides of the case. And yes, the 1300 would have covered the new piston and jug that is needed now. And that was all the parts coming from eBay, so it would be different sources. Is that what you were meaning? and the 1300 does not include labor, which would be another 600.00 to 1200.00 and I told them that I would cover the labor.
mr_lincoln
Mentor@josephtiffee
You have a good point if the Seller's listing states "We afford all cost if it's our fault" although I suspect they could turn around and challenge whether or not it was installed correctly and how would the defect be determined beforehand ...
And yes to what I was meaning with regard to having to source the $ 1,300 in parts needed to fix it again. Unless that Seller is a huge one and they are willing to foot all or part of the replacement parts cost you are basically SOL..
I am obviously sympathetic in a situation like this ...
josephtiffee
OPThey are one of eBay’s largest sellers. They are from China. and when I had the parts professionally installed, they’re the ones that told me that it was a failure due to a manufacturer defect in the piston wrist pin area
mr_lincoln
Mentor@josephtiffee
Ahhhh, a Seller from China. I wonder how they determined that the defect was from the manufacturer ... wonder if they have a Warranty for that part when they acquired it for resale from the manufacturer? More questions than answers on that score.