Need Advice: eBay Closed My INR Case Despite UPS Confirming Address Mismatch
Summary: lyc718 shared a troubling experience of buying an item on eBay that was not delivered to their address, despite the UPS showing it as delivered. UPS confirmed that the delivery address did not match their address but due to privacy, couldn't disclose the actual address. Despite substantial evidence provided by lyc718, including UPS case numbers and screenshots, eBay sided with the seller, stating the delivery address matched. mam98031 advised disputing the charge with the credit card company, sharing similar past experiences where this resolved the issue. lyc718 expressed disappointment in eBay's handling of the case and appreciated the advice given.
Need Advice: eBay Closed My INR Case Despite UPS Confirming Address Mismatch
I'm looking for advice from anyone who has experienced something similar.
I purchased an item on eBay but never received it. The seller provided a UPS tracking number that showed "Delivered."
I contacted UPS twice (Cases #0370507392 and #0370496207). Both UPS representatives told me the delivery address associated with the tracking number did not match the shipping address on my eBay order. They explained that, due to privacy rules, they could not disclose the actual address and that only the shipper could verify it. They also advised me to file a fraud report.
The circumstances appear consistent with a known tracking-number scam, where a valid tracking number is associated with a different delivery address. I repeatedly asked the seller to contact UPS or provide proof that the package was addressed to my shipping address. The seller refused each time.
I opened an INR case and later appealed, providing the UPS case numbers, UPS My Choice screenshots showing no incoming package to my address, photos showing the delivery location was not my house, and other supporting evidence.
What surprised me was that eBay's final decision stated the carrier confirmed the delivery address matched my shipping address. This directly contradicts what two UPS representatives told me. eBay did not provide any documentation supporting that statement, while I provided UPS case numbers and supporting evidence. The seller also provided no evidence that the package was addressed to my shipping address.
Has anyone experienced something similar or successfully escalated a case like this? Is there any avenue left within eBay, or is my only remaining option to dispute the charge with my credit card?
mam98031
MentorI've had this happen to me in the past. Since you have done everything you can within Ebay, your best bet is to go to your Credit Card Company and put it in dispute. It should work out for you.
lyc718
OPThank you for your advice. What infuriates me was that eBay did not appear to conduct any meaningful investigation at all. I provided UPS case numbers, photos, UPS My Choice screenshots, and other supporting evidence, yet it appears the responses simply sided with the seller based on the tracking status.
Even more concerning, eBay stated that the carrier confirmed the delivery address matched my shipping address. However, UPS Fraud detection team has now confirmed in writing that the package was actually delivered to a different address than my shipping address. That directly contradicts eBay's conclusion.
Neither eBay nor the seller provided any evidence supporting their decision, while I repeatedly provided evidence supporting my claim. This is deeply disappointing because it effectively enables tracking-number scams to continue if conflicting evidence from the carrier is ignored without any meaningful investigation.
mam98031
MentorI get it. In your shoes I'd find that frustrating too. I believe you have every right to how you feel. The good thing however is to know that it doesn't always happen the way it did for you and more importantly you still have an avenue to travel that will result in you getting your money back.
Please know that most transactions do not end this way. The vast majority of sellers are good and honest sellers. Also know that Ebay does get it right sometimes too.