My feedback was erased
I recently got the winning bid on a coin only to find that the listing was fraudulent. I soon found that the seller was reusing the same picture and same description for future auctions as the one used for my coin. I bid only $57.##, and the coin I got was roughly worth that, but the coin in the picture was worth much more than that; one of the subsequent auctions using the same picture and same description had a final bid of over $220.00.
I contacted the seller after I realized my coin wasn't the one in the picture and also alerted them to their fraudulent actions. They refunded me $10.00, but did not take down other listings using the same pics and description, so I left "Negative" feedback, and found that others were doing the same for the same reason-the coins they got were not what was pictured (various other coins, not what I had received (mine was a 1900 Morgan dollar, whereas others were talking about other Morgan dollars, Kennedy half dollars, etc.).
I received a request to change my feedback, so... reluctantly, I "upgraded" my "negative" to neutral. I noticed other negative comments had disappeared, while doing so, so I assumed they caved, too, and changed their comments.
This happened just a couple of weeks ago. Today I looked, and noticed new negative feedback, and lower "Neutral" feedback count than what I remembered seeing when I changed mine to neutral. I looked, and my neutral feedback was gone.
This seller has tens of thousands of "5" star ratings, but they are perpetually scamming people.
Is eBay helping them remove bad feedback? Again, mine disappeared after only a couple of weeks.
shipscript
Most coins are sold for bullion value (where the picture is not really important), rather than as a collectible, so pay attention to the category where the coins are listed.
eBay's system will automatically remove negative feedback for high volume sellers if they respond promptly to buyer complaints and offer a refund or replacement. Some sellers do take advantage of this to scam buyers who don't pay attention. If there is something truly nefarious about this seller, you can report a seller here for "violating one of eBay’s policies":
https://www.ebay.com/help/action?topicid=4022
Use the "other" option to report a high incidence of substituting an item that is different than the one pictured.
indigohut
OPThanks... this seller is definitely not selling coins for bullion. The coins listed are listed using the best terms possible to describe older coins.
The only way I could show high instances of them doing this is documenting other eBayer's negative feedback complaining of the same problem over a few weeks' time.
I appreciate the insight you provided and the guidance.