I accidentally sent 2 cards directly to buyer without getting it authenticated.

Question

Buyer is happy and left positive feedback. what happens next?

selforfun · Answer

Hi @cencal75

Since the buyer is happy and has already left positive feedback, you probably wonâ€™t run into any issues. But here are a few things to keep in mind:

What Happens Next?

Skipping eBayâ€™s Authenticity Guarantee

If your cards were eligible for eBayâ€™s Authenticity Guarantee but didnâ€™t go through the process, eBay might still reach out to you or the buyer.
That said, since the buyer got the cards and is happy, itâ€™s unlikely eBay will take any action.

No Payment Holds or Penalties

As long as the buyer has no complaints and the transaction is marked as complete, you should receive your funds as usual.
eBay doesnâ€™t automatically reverse payments just because authentication was skipped, especially if the buyer is satisfied.

Possible Risks for Future Sales

If eBay notices that authentication was bypassed, they could issue a warning or, in rare cases, limit your selling privileges.
In very uncommon situations, eBay might force a return, but since the buyer left positive feedback, thatâ€™s highly unlikely.

What Should You Do?

- Keep records â€“ Save messages, tracking info, and feedback in case thereâ€™s any issue later.
- Be upfront next time â€“ If this ever happens again, consider letting eBay know to stay in good standing.
- Follow authentication steps in the future â€“ It helps protect both you and the buyer.

Since this one worked out fine, youâ€™re probably in the clear, but itâ€™s always good to be aware of eBayâ€™s policies just in case. Hope this helps!