Well, looks like no matter how I cut it, I just have to bite the bullet, again, Thanks to all of you for taking your time to help me. Cheerio the nooo.
The Marketplace Facilitation sales tax laws require sales tax to be collected based on the delivery location of the item and not the sellers location. So eBay is required to charge the sales tax unless you are selling to a user in your own State for this particular item.
Yet when I would sell to someone in my bricks and mortar store, from New York or California, I do not charge them sales tax since they are buying in Pennsylvania. Doesn't make sense, well at least to me. Thanks for your help.
Yet when I would sell to someone in my bricks and mortar store, from New York or California, I do not charge them sales tax since they are buying in Pennsylvania. Doesn't make sense, well at least to me. Thanks for your help.
Not all laws make sense. Back in about 2018 the Supreme Court overturned a long held decision regarding the collection of sales tax online. They ruled that the State the item is delivered to will have its sales tax laws applied to the purchase once the State enacted Marketplace Facilitation sales tax laws. Over the years all States have enacted these laws so the State makes additional money from online purchases made by their residents.
Whether sales tax is charged depends on the law in the state the item is being shipped to, and to a lesser extent, the category in which the item is listed.
A shirt that might be untaxed in a clothing category might be taxed if listed in a sporting goods category, for instance.
This seems to be what a couple of you kind people are saying - Yet when I would sell to someone in my bricks and mortar store, from New York or California, I do not charge them sales tax since they are buying in Pennsylvania. Doesn't make sense, well at least to me , these days what does make sense!!! Thanks for your help, I appreciate your help. .
Yet when I would sell to someone in my bricks and mortar store, from New York or California, I do not charge them sales tax since they are buying in Pennsylvania.
A purchase made in a store in Pennsylvania is subject to Pennsylvania state law, which does not distinguish between buyers from other locations; imagine if everyone making a purchase in a store had to show ID to establish whether sales tax was due.
A purchase made on eBay, in contrast, is subject to the law of the state the item is being shipped to, since that information is already clearly established in advance.
wrap-yourself-in-luxury
OPWell, looks like no matter how I cut it, I just have to bite the bullet, again, Thanks to all of you for taking your time to help me. Cheerio the nooo.
wrap-yourself-in-luxury
OPI'm not trying to change payment methods - I only want to stop my buyers from paying sales tax on clothing. How can I set this up?
rock.star
Only your buyers in Pennsylvania are not charged sales tax on clothing.
Buyers in other states have to pay sales tax based on their state laws.
jacbarcollectibles
MentorThe Marketplace Facilitation sales tax laws require sales tax to be collected based on the delivery location of the item and not the sellers location. So eBay is required to charge the sales tax unless you are selling to a user in your own State for this particular item.
wrap-yourself-in-luxury
OPYet when I would sell to someone in my bricks and mortar store, from New York or California, I do not charge them sales tax since they are buying in Pennsylvania. Doesn't make sense, well at least to me. Thanks for your help.
wrap-yourself-in-luxury
OPYet when I would sell to someone in my bricks and mortar store, from New York or California, I do not charge them sales tax since they are buying in Pennsylvania. Doesn't make sense, well at least to me. Thanks for your help.
jacbarcollectibles
MentorNot all laws make sense. Back in about 2018 the Supreme Court overturned a long held decision regarding the collection of sales tax online. They ruled that the State the item is delivered to will have its sales tax laws applied to the purchase once the State enacted Marketplace Facilitation sales tax laws. Over the years all States have enacted these laws so the State makes additional money from online purchases made by their residents.
eburtonlab
MentorWhether sales tax is charged depends on the law in the state the item is being shipped to, and to a lesser extent, the category in which the item is listed.
A shirt that might be untaxed in a clothing category might be taxed if listed in a sporting goods category, for instance.
wrap-yourself-in-luxury
OPYes, I know this about personal and sporting goods category, e.g., T-shirts - Thanks for your help.
wrap-yourself-in-luxury
OPThis seems to be what a couple of you kind people are saying - Yet when I would sell to someone in my bricks and mortar store, from New York or California, I do not charge them sales tax since they are buying in Pennsylvania. Doesn't make sense, well at least to me , these days what does make sense!!! Thanks for your help, I appreciate your help. .
eburtonlab
MentorYet when I would sell to someone in my bricks and mortar store, from New York or California, I do not charge them sales tax since they are buying in Pennsylvania.
A purchase made in a store in Pennsylvania is subject to Pennsylvania state law, which does not distinguish between buyers from other locations; imagine if everyone making a purchase in a store had to show ID to establish whether sales tax was due.
A purchase made on eBay, in contrast, is subject to the law of the state the item is being shipped to, since that information is already clearly established in advance.