How do I fight back against a buyer who is clearly trying to scam me?
Summary: luckylootboxbiz shared their experience of encountering what they believe to be a buyer scam on eBay after reaching Top Rated Seller status. The buyer claimed only one speaker was delivered and it was damaged, despite luckylootboxbiz packaging both speakers securely. The seller believes the buyer is attempting to exchange a damaged speaker through fraudulent means. They offered a partial refund, which was rejected, and are now seeking advice on how to escalate the issue with eBay Support. They provided evidence disproving the buyer's claims and are asking the community for opinions and guidance on how to proceed.
I started my eBay business about 10 months ago, so I'm fairly new at this, but I recently surpassed 100 sales and was just awarded Top Rated Seller status, which I'm proud of. But now I'm dealing with my first buyer scam, which is exactly following a pattern that I've been warned about by others with more experience.
I sold a pair of Polk bookshelf speakers in flawless condition for full asking price, which was $146.66 after buyer-paid shipping and tax. I wrapped each of them in bubble wrap and packed them tightly in a quality box. These speakers weigh 12 pounds each so the box was 26 pounds and 23x18x13 inches, costing me nearly $50 to ship via FedEx. Less than an hour after it arrived, the buyer started an "Item Damaged" return request, stating "Only one of the two speakers was shipped, and the speaker received was damaged due to a lack of protective packaging." He included three photos showing one speaker with a damaged corner sitting in a small box with no bubble wrap and no scrapes or punctures on the inside of the box.
This starts off with something that I know with 100% certainty is a lie, because I personally boxed up both speakers and personally took that box to a FedEx Office store. I recognize this is asking you to believe me, but I didn't achieve Top Rated Seller status by creating listings for two perfect speakers and only shipping one broken speaker, and I'd never risk losing that status by doing that, right?
Further, the buyer's photos show the speaker sitting inside a cardboard box that has zero damage to the inside walls. Ask yourself how the hard, pointy corner of a heavy speaker could get broken without that cardboard getting punctured, scraped, or damaged in any way.
My theory is that this buyer dropped and damaged his speaker, or somehow acquired a broken speaker, then came up with a scheme to trade this broken speaker for two flawless speakers for free through a little eBay fraud.
eBay offered me three options:
Accept the return, and pay for the buyer to ship his one broken speaker back to me
Offer a full or partial refund, and let the buyer keep the item
Message the buyer
I chose to offer a partial refund of $20, with which I wrote the admittedly bold message: "We both know that you are lying about your claim that I only shipped one of the two speakers and that it arrived damaged due to a lack of protective packaging, and I have sufficient evidence to prove to eBay that you are lying. Despite that, I'm offering you a $20 refund and giving you a partial victory so that we can end this dispute quickly. I recommend you accept it. If you don't, this will get escalated to eBay Support, where I'll present my evidence that you are lying. I fully expect to win." The buyer quickly rejected the offer with no additional message.
The eBay documentation I've found states two different ways I can ask eBay to step in and help, but when I follow both sets of directions, I'm only presented with the same basic three options:
Accept the return, and pay for the buyer to ship his one broken speaker back to me
Offer a full refund, and let the buyer keep the item
Message the buyer
It says "You can choose how you’d like to respond. Remember to resolve the request by Oct 29." That is 3 days from now. So I'm stuck wondering, how can I ask eBay for help? Is there anyone out there who can answer this? I'd also love to know if you think eBay would side with me, given the reasons I've presented, which in short are:
The speakers weigh 12 pounds each and I shipped a box that weighs 26 pounds, so the buyer's claim that "Only one of the two speakers was shipped" is ridiculous.
The hard, pointy corner of the speaker is broken, but there's no damage to the inside walls of the box in the buyer's photos showing the damaged speaker sitting inside it. If the buyer's claim that "the speaker received was damaged due to a lack of protective packaging" was true, how did the cardboard not get damaged by the speaker?
I'm a Top Rater Seller who wouldn't have achieved that status and wouldn't risk losing that status by doing unethical things like listing two flawless speakers (complete with thorough photos) and shipping one broken speaker.
Thank you so much in advance for your expertise and opinions!
disneyshopper
MentorAccept the return and a prepaid shipping label will be provided to the buyer. Once tracking shows Delivered, you will have 2 days to refund the buyer. Once that is done, you can then Report the Buyer for misusing the ebay Money Back Guarantee.
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/resolving-buyer-issues/reporting-issue-buyer?id=4084
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/resolving-buyer-issues/resolving-buyer-issues?id=4076&st=12&pos=6&query=Resolving%20buyer%20issues&intent=report%20buyer&context=DEFAULT_SELLER&docId=HELP1042