HELP!! Sold a $2.5K item. Buyer disputed, kept item and got refunded !!
SORRY, this is a LONG READ!
We sold a UV printer on eBay for ~$2700 with ink sets accessories and shipping.
Buyer waited exactly 90 days to contact us and said that they were having trouble printing black ink.
Said that the manufacturer wouldn't help them as they were not the original purchaser.
I contacted manufacturer and asked why they wouldn't support them - they mentioned that they HAD given them support regarding the ink not printing.
3 days later the buyer filed a "Item not as listed" complaint.
We fought the dispute with all of the evidence we could (the listing no longer showed up for us to screen shot since it was after 90 days).
Another month goes by (120+ days after the sale) and dispute is marked in favor of buyer.
I called eBay Support who first told me I need to contact "them". I finally got out of support who "them" was. They told me to call Visa as the buyer filed a dispute through their credit card.
I tried that, and as I suspected, they could not help at all citing that the dispute number on eBay would mean nothing in their system. That CRS asked me what the credit card number was related to the dispute. I tried to explain that I, as the seller would never have that info. This went back and forth until I gave up on that.
I called eBay support again and asked for a supervisor. I talked with Roger for over half an hour who assured me over and over that everything would be fine and that we wouldn't have the $2700 debited from us, adding that we'd get an email in the next day or two. That never happened, nothing was ever sent. He had added that the dispute should never have gotten that far with eBay 30day returns policy.
After a couple days of not getting anything in email, I called eBay support again, asking for a supervisor. This time I spoke with Diana for over half an hour, who also assured me over and over that eBay would take care of us and would fight the case against Visa. Diana mentioned that it seemed as if the buyer knew what they were doing to dispute on the 90the day to "game the system in their favor" I asked if there is a situation where the buyer still wins the case and gets to keep the printer bundle. She never directly replied to that, but said they would fight it and that we have "Seller protection" after the first 30 days. I got a case # via email after this call.
A day later I got an email from Bhagiratha at eBay stating that there's nothing eBay can do and sent a link to RBASellerHub if I wanted to open a fraudulent case against the buyer.
Since it's been so long (120+ days) none of the info we would need is even on eBay's site any longer. I replied back stating this and asked several questions including "Was the buyer required to return the printer?"
This question hadn't been answered yet, and it was not this time either.
I sent another email explaining that the suggest route to report the buyer is not possible and politely demanded to know if the sell is going to be allowed to keep the printer and our money.
This was replied to, but again my questions about the buyer being allowed to keep the printer and our money has never been addressed. I was told "Unfortunately the time frame has passed, please understand that time frame was completely up to financial institution, eBay never involves with any payment disputes. So, kindly understand that the times frame for appeal the outcome has expired."
I replied yet again, only asking specifically about the seller keeping the printer and our money. This email was never replied to by eBay.
In what world is this fair in any sense?
Is there anything we can do? Any suggestions would be welcome!