eBay Watch Authentication ~ Stoll & Co ~ Is a Joke - Authentic When I Bought but NOT when Resold
Ahhh the story of many watches. So during the Pandemic I decided to start collecting watches. Not your Timex, Seiko or Casio. But high end watches, particularly Panerai. Now mind you, this was prior to eBay launching their Watch Authentication Guarantee. I bought a Panerai out of Australia and during shipment eBay cancelled the seller's account. The watch arrived, and I took it to my watchmaker to authenticate, low and behold it was fake. The seller harassed me by opening a new account (no idea how they did that eBay)
Next bought another from Florida, but oddly enough, when the tracking was uploaded, the shipment was coming from Abu Dhabi. It arrived, and I again took it to my watch maker to have it checked. Once again, fake. It took 3 weeks for me to get my funds back.
But this is where the story turns. In chasing eBay Customer Service, I somehow got through to someone in Salt Lake City, Utah. He was a veteran and funny enough, he was involved in eBay standing up their high end item authentication program, which was in its infancy. We stayed in contact and I was able to help him in tracking down bogus Panerai watch listings. Not just in the US but in Europe too.
Now eBay launches their Watch Authentication Program in Dayton, OH, with Stoll & Co. At the time Google rating was 2.5 stars.
I bought a Panerai out of California. It ships to Stoll & Co in Dayton and I'm notified they cannot verify the authenticity and they/eBay cancels the transaction and ships it back to the seller. All I can think of is whew, got out of another counterfiet Panerai.
Fast forward to May of 2022, an advert for a Panerai PAM00250 Daylight Chronograph pops up. Panerai only makes a small number of watch models and with the PAM00250 they only made 750 of those. So I pull the trigger and purchase the watch. I track it to Stoll & Co in Dayton, no emails from them and then it starts moving by Fedex to me. It was perfect no issues with the watch and I loved it.
Unfortunately this Febuary I put it back up on eBay to sell. Finally at the end of March a buyer and I shipped it to Stoll & Co in Dayton to have it re-authenticated, even though they authenticated it for me. Saturday April 1, I recieved a message from the buyer that Stoll & Co emailed them and they could not authenticate the buckle. So I get on the phone to try to get with a eBay Customer Service Rep. (Not easy) I asked how could the buckle be counterfiet if its the same watch with the same strap & buckle I bought it with and Stoll & Co authenticated for me?!?!? The eBay Customer Service Rep said to have the watch sent back to me and they would work with me on the issue of the buckle.
Ok so on Monday I reached out to eBay Customer Service and there is no way to call them now, it pushes you to the eBay community for answers. Needless to say I did'nt think the community could help, so I got on Twitter and got through to someone (Lori). We Direct Messaged, and she check with Stoll & Co and Said they would stand by Stoll & Co on their accessment of the buckle. OK, so WHAT HAPPENED WHEN I PURCHASED IT?!?!?!? They did't catch it?!?!?!? And when they went through the notes from my phone with the eBay Customer Service Rep, they said sorry, we are NOT going to DO ANYTHING FOR YOU!!!
So, eBay if you're listening.
1. Where was the REAL AUTHENTICATION of the watch when I bought it????
2. You side with the buyers on majority of the cases and where were you for me?!?!?!?
3. If you ARE going to USE STOLL & CO. I recommend you have THEM/YOU create a QR Code to identify watches that have already been authenticated through your program!!!!!
4. Don't have your eBay Customer Service Rep tell customers on the phone with them that they will work with an eBayer who used the eBay Watch Authentication Program to come up with a solution for when they bought it. Only to have your Twitter eBay Customer Service Rep say sorry your out of luck, "Thats our final decision."
I am so disappointed with eBay that I am going to tapper back on my activity on the site and transition to a platform that has better customer service and treats everyone fairly...
It arrives and I unbox it. Please see photos attached.
twinkling.smile
Sorry this happened.
If you want to connect to the right team, go to
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/selling-tools/ebay-authenticity-guarantee?id=4644
Scroll to the bottom and click on "Contact us".
Add 'agent' in the chat box that popped up.
Choose for the call to you.
I hope this works.