eBay needs to overhaul their Seller rating system
Here's one example. This is obviously a scammer, highly rated by eBay, yet only having 50 percent positive feedback. Seriously? This account needs to be banned. Reported, no effect.
 
highscore.sales
1 comment
eburtonlab
MentoreBay does not use feedback to judge sellers; that is for buyers.
Top rated seller is evaluated on a monthly basis, I believe, so a seller that was top rated last month will continue to have that rating until the next evaluation.
Buyers should use their own judgement rather than relying solely on eBay to police the site, even though I agree with you that eBay could do more to stop sellers like that sooner rather than later.
With less than 50% feedback, I suspect that the seller will not sell many more items, but you can report the seller directly to eBay here:
https://www.ebay.com/help/action?topicId=4850