eBay Denied My Fraud Report Multiple Times — Buyer Altered Return Label & Sent Empty Box.
Hi everyone,
I really need advice from the community because I’m running into a brick wall with Support.
I had a return where the buyer tampered with the eBay-issued return label. USPS confirmed all of this:
1. The buyer changed the tracking number
They used a method called digit transposition — rearranging the digits of the original USPS tracking number so the label still scans, but no longer matches the correct tracking eBay created.
2. The buyer altered the return address
The package was rerouted to a completely different business instead of the proper seller return address.
3. The package was confirmed empty
I visited the rerouted location and the business confirmed the box contained nothing.
4. USPS confirmed the label was manually altered
I have the tracking history, internal notes, and GPS scan showing the parcel going to the altered address.
5. I filed a police report
This is clearly intentional return fraud.
⸻
The problem:
Despite all this, eBay has denied my fraud report multiple times, saying that tracking shows “delivered.â€
But the “delivery†was only the result of the buyer altering the return label, not a legitimate return.
I’ve provided USPS documentation, photos, and the police report, but Support keeps closing it.
What are my real options here?
Is there a specific department, seller protections team, or path to escalation that actually works?
Any advice or experience from other sellers would be greatly appreciated.
mr_lincoln
MentorhI @wooit8
We see the False tracking number scam reported here all of the time. I it is truly a growing issue for eBay and other internet sales venues. It happens more often when Sellers use it on outbound shipping but we have seen it happen on returns like yours as well. Would this happen to be the $ 570 sale you made on October 29th?
I would suggest reaching out to eBay with the documentation you have from USPS via Social Media instead of trying to talk with their regular phone support (often 3rd party off-shore call centers).
-Contacting eBay via Social Media:
Contact customer service by sending a PRIVATE message on social media. Customer service verifies your identity before responding.
https://x.com/askebay
https://www.facebook.com/ebay
https://www.instagram.com/ebayforsellers/
@devon@ebay
@elizabeth@ebay
@kyle@ebay
Folks, this one needs to get passed on to the eBay Shipping Team that is looking into the False tracking number scam. The Buyer obviously needs to be banned permanently from eBay and it sounds like the OP has enough information and documentation to allow eBay to do that.
wooit8
OPYes, that is the order — the $570 sale from October 29th.
Thank you for the detailed explanation and the guidance. I will follow your advice and reach out to eBay through the social media channels you listed. if anyone from eBay is reviewing this thread, the case ID is 5367845318.
Thanks again for pointing me in the right direction.
mr_lincoln
Mentor@wooit8
You are more than welcome and if nothing else you deserve a courtesy reimbursement from eBay for the total transaction. Filing a police report was a great idea because this is internet crime, period. Many criminals, thieves, con artists, etc have switched to pursuing their trade on the internet where there is no infrastructure to catch and prosecute them. They can now ply their trade in the comfort of their own home, in their pajamas sipping their Starbuck's Mocha-Choca-Steal-a Lotta ...