Damages cause by Carrier Negligence
I have been a 100% performer for 20 years and feel I deserve some consideration. I am 68 years old and do not need the stress that I have endured in the last two months.
I am frustrated that eBay always takes the side of the Buyer (in all of its posted documentation) and does not help the long term faithful sellers as in my case when UPS damaged an expensive insured item and did NOT pay me the full amount sold and then turned around and said that I have to take up my case with eBay not them. Even though I do NOT accept returns nor do refunds. In good faith, I gave the buyer a full refund because they received an inoperable highly damaged high end stereo receiver that per photos and video on the eBay listing was working in perfect condition when provided to UPS Store in Loveland Colorado.
I will summarize, I recently sold an expensive and fully insured Marantz Model 4400 Stereo/Quadraphonic receiver on 4/3/2026 for $2800. UPS damaged a beautiful Marantz 4400 receiver on its journey from Colorado to Illinois that the buyer admits was packaged extremely well and suffered abuse from UPS. From the damage incurred, itlooked like it was dropped several feet off the truck. The Marantz 4400 arrived inoperable from a severe drop and abuse from UPS. I should have received a check for:
$2800 + $93.36 (for insurance and UPS Ground shipping) Total = $2893.36
Instead, UPS Claims admits the damage and sent me a check for $1076.36 and said any difference for the full amount needs to be taken up with eBay for the difference of: $2893.36 - $1076.36 = $1817.
I have asked eBay for help and have not heard anything. I am patient, but I have not been treated well and lied to. I am asking for $1817 as fair compensation just to be whole again. I requested a call from eBay and talk to a representative that recommended that I post my issue on this forum and that they could not do anything to help me. I purchased the shipping label from eBay and have screenshots of the transaction with shipping Insurance for $2800. The carrier admitted that they damaged the item and only sent me a check for $1076.36 and that the remainder would have to come from eBay. I do not understand this and I am asking for eBay to step in and help me and pay me $1817 as fair compensation. I feel like eBay is ignoring me. What do I do?
mmartinez90
3 comments
rfmtm
MentorIf you insured it directly through UPS for the full value of what it sold for, then UPS is on the hook up to that amount, if not repairable for less. If part of the insurance was not through UPS, then the third party insurer has to pay anything over $100.
For this value of an item UPS usually will go out and pick the unit up from the buyer at no charge, then either pay the full claim amount and keep the item, or return it to you with possibly a partial payout.
Did you use Ebay UPS or did you use your own account or some other third party account?
mudshark61369
Mentor@mmartinez90 ,
I was interrupted by a phone call and posted the last reply before finishing it.
"Even though I do NOT accept returns nor do refunds. In good faith, I gave the buyer a full refund because they received an inoperable highly damaged high end stereo receiver".
Your No Returns policy does not fly in the face of eBay's Money Back Guarantee policy, unless a buyer requests a return for a Buyer's remorse reason. If an item is damaged in shipping, doesn't work, is missing items... etc. You have to accept returns and refund the buyer.
In a case like this one where the shipper damages an item, you cannot make them wait until the shipper resolves the issue, but have to issue a refund and deal with the shipper on your own. Though the buyer may have to save the item and package for the carrier to pick it up, and inspect it.
mudshark61369
Mentor@mmartinez90 ,
UPS' insurance provider probably got an average price from a few sources and figured that is what the unit was worth. You can appeal the Payout but first I suggest that you gather all of the evidence you can find to back your case.
First do an ebay Advanced search for "Marantz Model 4400 Stereo/Quadraphonic receiver" Category > Consumer electronics then check the Sold - Completed listings boxes. Down load screen shots or print the listings for that unit that have sold in working condition, including yours and your Order Details showing the price, and the UPS shipping and insurance receipt. A copy of your refund payment would also help and if your buyer sent you photos of the unit that show the package damage add them as well.
Then do a Google search for "How do I appeal a UPS insurance claim refund amount" The A.I. information is helpful and there are also Reddit and Quora articles and videos that tell you how to appeal the UPS settlement.
"I am frustrated that eBay always takes the side of the Buyer (in all of its posted documentation) and does not help the long term faithful sellers as in my case when UPS damaged an expensive insured item and did NOT pay me the full amount sold and then turned around and said that I have to take up my case with eBay not them".
eBay cannot help you in a situation like this one, since they are not a part of the shipping contract. Your dispute is with UPS not ebay. UPS saying ebay should help you is their way of deflecting you away from appealing the claim.
eBay's customer service reps who work for a hired 3rd party Call/Chat center are given a play book to read from when there are issues. That book does not cover all issues, and certainly not one where the Shipper is at fault for shipping damage.