Buyer Killed the Daphnia I sent Him, and then filed a return because they were dead. How do I appeal after Ebay Approved the Return
Summary: gstrausslaw is selling live daphnia on eBay and has encountered issues with buyers claiming the daphnia arrived dead. They require a video of the unopened package showing no movement within two hours of delivery to verify claims, but eBay has approved a return without this proof, leading to frustration with the platform's inconsistency. inceptions and momtoabeautifuldaughter advise that eBay's policies favor buyers in such disputes and suggest refunding and blocking future purchases from problematic buyers. house*of*paws explains that sellers cannot enforce stricter return requirements than what eBay stipulates in their Money Back Guarantee, and recommends handling such sales on a personal website. gstrausslaw argues that the video requirement provides necessary proof and protects sellers from being responsible for buyer neglect, but feels eBay's current policy does not support sellers adequately.
I sell live daphnia (tropical fish food) on ebay. Occasionally they die in transit. Buyers are required by my terms of sale to submit a brief video of the unopened bag showing no movement within two hours of delivery. This requirement proves the buyer did not cause the death by either leaving the package outside in heat or cold for a prolonged period or open the bag and do something that caused the death. On at least two occasions I have won appeals on return cases because this was not done. I had a pending return case in which the buyer did not submit a video and did report the DOA and provide photographs but only five hours after the daphnia were delivered. I detailed my reasons for not accepting the return in the item messaging with photos and excerpts from the tracking. Today I received notice EBay had approved the return and upon affirming that the item was returned they would refund the purchase price.. I was given no way to respond or appeal. The notice suggests I can appeal only after the item is returned and presumably after the money has been refunded. This is different from how my prior cases were handled.
I no longer trust Ebay's dispute resolution practices because they are not consistent and in this case could not possibly have read and understood the situation. The daphnia are dead. What purpose is it to return them? The buyer does not dispute that he left the package outside in searing heat for five hours before he brought it in, or that he failed to provide the required videos in the proper time frame. If I can't enforce the terms of sale, how can I deal with dishonest buyers, or folks who cause the daphnia to die themselves?
Can I stop the return and refund or do I have to wait until I receive the return to appeal?
house*of*paws
MentorHi @gstrausslaw
I'm very sorry, but eBay sellers CANNOT stipulate that buyers submit to more rigorous return requirements than outlined in eBay's Money Back Guarantee.
Your rules make sense ... and you are free to enforce them ... AS LONG AS you do it on your own website.
gstrausslaw
OPIm sorry, but I haven't. Ebay requires my daphnia be delivered alive. The video requirement is designed to provide validity to the buyers claim that the daphnia were dead WHEN DELIVERED. If the daphnia died because the buyer failed to properly care for the package for five hours after tracking shows it was delivered, left it to bake in the hot sun on his porch or opened the bag and placed the daphnia in bad water or at an inappropriate temp and killed them, how is that my responsibility? Thanks for letting me clarify my position.
momtoabeautifuldaughter
MentorShipping live fish seems like a recipe for disaster to me. I checked just for curiosity and it shows 4-9 day delivery to me. That is plenty of time for fish to die and also your 2 hour video requirement means diddly.
You need to accept the return of the dead fish (gross) and refund when you get them back or just refund the buyer and move on.
gstrausslaw
OPAgain, they're not fish. We ship priority Mail which usually takes 4 to 5 days, not 4 to 9. Daphnia can survive to 6 or 7 days, although 3 to 4 is optimum. As to my video requirement, Ive seen it or something like it applied to mechanical devices that supposedly dont work, animals, fish, and some plants. Its standard for daphnia sellers on Ebay. Look at lilswimmers, one of the nore successful. The profit margin in selling daphnia is thin. Allowing buyers to claim DOA without some proof 1) that the daphnia are actually dead; and 2) that thry died prior to delivery, is unfair to sellers and an invitation to go out of business. But thanks for the advice.
inceptions
MentorHi @gstrausslaw
You cannot enforce your requirement to send a video of a dead fish within 2 hours of receipt. Obviously, a buyer doesn't order a fish and purposely cause it to die just to have to return it.
Shipping live animals that can take up to five days of transit time (or longer in some cases) especially during the summer is just asking for problems. There is no way you can prove when the fish died. The package can sit out in the sun on the loading dock of the post office or sorting center, the package can sit on a hot delivery truck all day before delivery, not to mention in sitting the cargo hold of a plane or out on the tarmac before loading.
You can avoid having the dead fish returned to you at your expense by just refunding when the buyer opens a case for an item that is not as described. When the buyer opens the case, you can request that he attach a photo of the expired fish.
gstrausslaw
OPYou should understand the context before you respond. Daphnia are not fish. They are small crustaceans sold as food for tropicals, newts, axolotls and the like. Second, it cant be my burden to prove the daphnia died prior to delivery. That opens the door to anyone who wants a free second order. Third, I never said someone would kill their daphnia on purpose, but like this buyer, through neglect or ignorance. Third, I am not the only seller of daphnia who has this requirement. Its standard for sellers of live fish, live fish food, and some plants to require some basic proof of death begore honoring a request for replacement. Fourth, you entirely missed the question. I asked what, procedurally could be done, not whether I am in the wrong business. And for your information, I have been successful in having Ebay rule favorably on the enforceability of my video requirement.
inceptions
MentorSorry. Just replace the word fish with fish food in my post and everything I wrote still applies.
I never said you were in the wrong business. If you are in your business however, what you have described as the problem that arises is to be expected.
Procedurally, as you already know, eBay will almost always find in favor of the buyer in a he said/she said situation unless the buyer has a history of abusing the Money Back Guarantee or there are other extenuating circumstances. I did answer your question about how to avoid having the dead live fish food returned to you. Just refund without requiring the return.
I understand you don't like the answer, but we aren't here just to give answers that members want to hear. We are here to give the answers and advice the poster needs to hear.
Each selling category comes with it's own level of risk. If you sell in a high-risk category for fraud, you will experience more fraud. If you sell in a high-risk category for death or damage due to extreme temperatures, etc., then you will experience more refund requests when items don't arrive alive.
Second, it cant be my burden to prove the daphnia died prior to delivery. That opens the door to anyone who wants a free second order.
You don't have to prove it, nor can you. You can avoid a free second order, by refunding and then blocking the buyer from buying from you in the future if you don't want to deal with the buyer again.
https://www.ebay.com/bmgt/buyerrequirements
gstrausslaw
OPI can block the buyer without refunding. Here's the problem. The shipping of live creatures of any description is certainly problematic. I'm acquainted with all the problems. But those problems are no different from the problems that exist for those sellers who successfully sell through their own websites online. There are many folks out there doing just that, and I'm one of them.
Here's the issue I want to address with ebay. The video I require and the time frame I require it in allow me to verify that death occurred, and that it occurred in the time frame during which I was responsible for the shipment. This is a standard requirement for shipment of living creatures. In this day and age when everyone has a cellphone, it's no burden to require buyers to take a five second video, or to have someone at home to bring the daphnia indoors and put them in a culture container within two hours. The potential for abuse from the buyer side if this requirement is useless is much greater. Any buyer can claim the shipment was DOA and request either a replacement or a refund and I'm virtually helpless to deny him. The fact that I can block him after the refund or replacement is not a remedy, because the damage is done and the word is out. He can work that con through his friends, his relatives or his agents. He can spread the word. Allowing me to appeal after Ebay has siezed my funds to refund him is not a remedy. It's my cash. I can't be forced to give ebay carte blanche to seize my funds. I'm a retired attorney. I'm not speaking out of my ass. You know as well as I do that Ebay resolves the dispute by giving up the refund because its easy and quick and because Sellers will give way to avoid any interruption or harm to their business, whereas for buyers it's a one and done. So the seller gets the short end of the stick.
What you're telling me, with respect, is that this is the way it is and I should just be a good boy and give up the refund. You've not addressed the fairness issue because it's just too much trouble to actually consider the facts and do what's fair to everyone not just in this case but as a matter of Ebay policy. And this case is a great example of how buyers abuse the system. This particular buyer lied to me in writing twice and failed to deny that he left the daphnia outside on his porch in the sun for five hours in Southern California where temps were forecasted to be above 85F. He never sent a video and his argument was that I never sent him a notice two days in advance so he didn't know when it would be delivered. His text messages range from childish to incoherent and present literally no credible denial of any of that. I don't know if you have access to the item messaging but if you do, it's an entertaining read.
If this guy can get away with so dubious a claim, anyone can. So for my own sake and because it just doesn't work where live creature transport is involved, I think this is a bad policy. It only works for Ebay, because again, it's quick and easy. For sellers, its a source of great angst and unhappiness, and it carves into an already thin profit margin. And it leaves little doubt whose side you're on.
inceptions
Mentor@gstrausslaw
Fairness? As a retired attorney, you already know that life isn't always fair.
What I'm explaining to you is what the policy is along with why you cannot pinpoint the time of death for the fish food. I didn't tell you to be a "good boy," but as a retired attorney, you know what a contract is and as you signed it when you listed your item for sale.
As far as your buyer's "dubious" claim that the package sat out in in the sun... I don't know how you determined that the package was in the sun in 85 degree heat...what about the package sitting on the delivery truck all day as the carrier made his rounds sitting in 120 degree heat? I replied earlier with several examples of where the fish food could have expired before it got even close to the buyer's location.
The bottom line is that you don't know where the fish food died. All the buyer knows is that the fish food is dead. And that is enough for the buyer to win the dispute on eBay.
One more note...you are not obligated to refund or replace. You are only obligated to refund. Whether or not you replace is up to you.