Buyer claims the item was stolen from their mailbox
In the past, I did have a buyer whose package was lost and the PO refunded me so I could refund the buyer. However, today, I received a "item not received" case and the tracking number noted that the package was delivered.
The buyer stated "my mailbox was broken into and my mail was stolen, which included your package. I submitted the package to usps as stolen and they advised me to ask you to use your insurance to refund my purchase. Please let me know if you need my case number." I asked for the case number figuring I would contact USPS on Monday but then they said "Case number is XXXXXXXX. USPS also told me to forward the email they sent to me, basically admitting that my items were stolen. I just need your email and I can send it to you as proof."
Needless to say, I don't feel comfortable providing my email to a stranger and taking conversations off of ebay's platform is a big no-no for me and ebay, both. Considering that I have the USPS case number, I am not sure why I need the buyer to forward USPS's email to me.
What would you do in my position?
glorybells
You don’t need to do anything. When a package is stolen after delivery, it’s not even 0.000001% your problem. This is 100% the buyers responsibility; it’s the responsibility of all buyers to ensure that they have a safe location for packages to be delivered to. If they open a case with eBay, respond with the tracking number showing delivery, and eBay will close the case in your favor.
rock.star
If a buyer item stolen after the tracking number shows delivery it is now between them and the Post office.
You need to enter the tracking number into the case.
Insurance cannot be claimed on a item that shows as delivered.