Beware of a new scam that buyers and eBay are doing together
Summary: deadheadtom33 shared a frustrating experience selling on eBay, where buyers can still demand refunds even if an item is listed as 'No Returns Accepted.' They described a scenario where a buyer requested a refund for an item clearly marked as non-working, and eBay provided limited response options for sellers. krazzykats and others discussed similar challenges, highlighting eBay's buyer protection policies. inceptions and mr_lincoln pointed out that understanding eBay’s return policies is crucial for sellers. Surprisingly, deadheadtom33 successfully appealed the refund case, getting their money back, though they expressed concern about potential repeat fraud. The conversation underscored the importance of accurate item listing and knowledge of eBay policies.
So, when you list an item as "No Returns Accepted", it literally means NOTHING. I had a buyer buy an item from me I described as not working, in need of repair and possibly only good for parts and as "No Returns Accepted". The buyer knows this before bidding, and, sure enough, receives the item and immediately asks for a refund. eBay does not tell you that you only have three days to respond to the refund claim. Now, here is the screwy part. As a seller, you are only given two options, "Refund in full" or, "Refund part of the sale price". NOWHERE is there a "dispute refund claim" option.
I called twice on this and not one eBay customer service person told me that what you are supposed to do is offer a partial refund, YOU as the seller must pay for the return label and, once you get the item back, APPEAL the refund claim... and, even if eBay sides with you, you are still out the cost of the return label!!! eBay does not cover that. And, it gets worse, if you do not respond to the buyer refund claim, the buyer gets a full refund AND gets to keep the item! Which of course the buyer did so it's a great double dip scam of the worst sort.
eBay is really doing downhill aiding and abetting fraud schemes. Why even offer, "Returns Not Accepted" if that phrase literally means nothing and buyers can ask for a refund for any reason and get one?!
deadheadtom33
OPWell, in a STUNNING turn of events, I appealed the refund claim and eBay sided with me and denied the refund... or at least refunded the money the buyer paid me back to me... no clue if they also refunded the buyer which would not surprise me as this would encourage the buyer to try this approach again.
fashionsandbeauty4u
Mentor@deadheadtom33
I looked at your sold listings and none of them show the Condition as being "For Parts or Not Working".
I did see a fishing reel where the description indicates it's for parts, but putting that in the listing is not enforceable. The Condition is "Used", which means it's fully functional.
Not every category allows a listing for parts. Sporting Goods only allows New or Used.
Because the Condition in that listing states the reel is fully functional, that would be how the Buyer was able to open an Item Not as Described refund request.
mr_lincoln
MentorHi @deadheadtom33
I need to weigh in on this one mainly because of my views on eBay Return policies. I happen to agree with you that No returns on listings that are for Parts Only - Not working should prevent a return and refund.
You may not know this but No returns accepted is the DEFAULT return policy on all eBay listing tools and that is intentional. Meaning eBay wants new Sellers to think they are protected against items being returned and will keep all of the money from their sales. I lost count of the times I have read here where a Seller says, "But I don't accept returns!!!" when one is forced on them.
The Return Policy setting on listing tools should be similar to the Conditions choices, meaning a list appears with explanation of what each Return Policy does and does not cover.
Since eBay launched 30 day Free returns that is what I use. Over all the years I have only had one item sold as Parts only returned. It was an HO train and the Buyer said they tried to fix it but couldn't and returned it.
inceptions
MentorHi @deadheadtom33
There is a big difference between eBay "aiding and abetting" fraud schemes and a seller who doesn't take the time to learn eBay policies before listing items and ends up surprised how things work, especially after being a member for 26 years.
I don't know which item is in question, but I didn't see any recent sold items that stated "for parts only - non-working" in the title or that used the corresponding item condition on the listing. Maybe I missed it. If you did all of this and prominently pictured and described the items defects, you may have luck with an appeal.
This policy has been the same for years and years and years.
Your options were to refund in full and allow the buyer to keep the item, offer a partial refund (which the buyer can accept or reject), or pay for a return label and refund after the item is received back.
krazzykats
MentorI made a sale, but the buyer wanted to return the item. Since the shipping was so pricey, I decided to refund without having it sent back, as it would have cost me double shipping.
In the end, I lost both the item and the original shipping expenses.
deadheadtom33
OPWell that sucks but it's not surprising. eBay has really gone downhill the last few years in their, "protect the buyer at all costs" mentality which allows buyer fraud and misuse
momtoabeautifuldaughter
Mentor@deadheadtom33 which item was it? I don't see any of your sold listings that state As Is Non Working
deadheadtom33
OPShimano's Bantam Curado CU100B Green Baitcast Reel
Copied and pasted from the ad description:
Shimano Bantam Curado CU100B green baitcasting reel in poor condition. The handle turns but the spool does not and the rear clicker button that releases the spool the cast is stuck in place. This is pretty much a parts reel unless you have the ability to take it apart and fix it.
This is the old model made in Japan and they are not made anymore so this is a perfect parts reel for someone to repair other reels or, again, if you have the know-how, you can probably fix this one but I'm not making any guarantees.
This reel is sold as is with no refunds.
momtoabeautifuldaughter
MentorUsed: An item that has been used previously. The item may have some signs of cosmetic wear, but is fully operational and functions as intended. This item may be a floor model or store return that has been used.
It was listed as Used......this is the eBay definition of Used.
deadheadtom33
OPYes but the buyer certainly should have read the ad description to get the full story, correct? No one should make any buying decision on the word, "used" without looking at all of the pictures and reading the ad description.
eBay auctions are supposed to be with old Caveat Emptor / Let the buyer beware and seeing, "This reel is sold as is with no refunds" should be all the buyer needs to know BEFORE bidding and winning an auction.
inceptions
Mentor@deadheadtom33
That's your opinion, but this is eBay's website and eBay makes their policies. Sellers cannot list the item condition as Used if it's for parts only and expect to win a case. And sellers should without fail put "FOR PARTS ONLY" in the listing title.
The listing includes conflicting information. When that happens, the buyer is justified in opening an item not as described case. All the information (description, photos, item specifics and condition) must match.
It doesn't do any good to be upset with the policy or the consequences if the policy isn't followed. We all agree to every eBay policy by virtue of using eBay... whether we like the policies or not. This is not a scam, this is a mistake on the seller's part. Hopefully the seller will learn from it and not make the same mistake again.
krazzykats
MentorYes, it's the eBay way.
Used, non-working items will have a higher risk for returns.