As a seller, I wish to dispute the buyer's reason for return
Summary: fraulau15 sought advice on handling a return initiated by a buyer on eBay for a dirndl dress. The seller argued that the item was not defective and highlighted that an open seam on the dress was intentional and typical of similar garments. They questioned whether they should refund only the selling price and avoid covering return shipping costs, as they aim to maintain a positive rating.
Hello,
Here is the message I sent the buyer, after I was contacted by ebay that the buyer had initiated the return of a dirndl dress:
Hello! I will of course be happy to refund you, however, before proceeding with a return, please notice that the front skirt seam you are showing is always open with no hooks or snaps for several inches below the bodice for ease in putting the dress on. This area is always covered by the apron. Here are photos of 3 other authentic Dirdl I own with the same open seam. Please let me know if you still wish to return. Please note: buyer pays return shipping.I hope this helps!
Here are the photos the buyer sent when initiating the return:

I wish to dispute this for 2 reasons:
I don't want a return showing "item defective" when it was not.
I don't want to refund original shipping, since the item was not defective. Would I normally just refund the selling price for the return of an item when the buyer simply changed their mind?
I'm not terribly concerned about the $6 cost of shipping, though I'd like to avoid it. I have 100% positive ratings and would like to keep it that way. The item is absolutely not defective.
Please let me know how I can proceed!
I just received the item back and need to refund by 10/23.
Thank you for your help.
Kim Lauzon
jacbarcollectibles
MentorIf the buyer opened an "Item not as described" case you must accept the return, provide a prepaid return label and give a full refund once the item is returned. You cannot dispute this type of case. If you do then eBay will find for the buyer, give you a defect on your account and refund the buyer from your money with no refund of the seller fees.
Once you have refunded you can report the buyer for misusing the money back guaranty but this will not get you any money back. it just internally mark the buyers account to see if they make a habit of using this return method.
fraulau15
OPThank you so much for this helpful information. The reason for return was " item defective", not " item not s described." &I imagine the same information you've given applies?
After I was notified of the return by ebay (not by the buyer), I sent the info above to the buyer. But I believe they cannot change the reason for return anyway? Assuming they just didn't like it, or it didn't fit, it doesn't matter because it was was already initiated as "item defective"?
Thanks again.
KL