A buyer disputed an item as "wrong item" via Paypal and won; admitted it was the correct/working item in messages.
Summary: insulinman14 shared a frustrating experience with a buyer who disputed an item as incorrect through PayPal, resulting in insulinman14 paying all associated fees. The dispute was not visible through their PayPal account, and both eBay and PayPal were unable to assist, suggesting small claims court as the only option. gosimus explained that disputing the claim might have been a mistake, as eBay often sides with buyers in 'Not As Described' claims. They advised that accepting returns and hoping the buyer doesn’t return the item could be a better strategy, highlighting that buyers can escalate to PayPal or their credit card if dissatisfied.
I had a buyer, presumably scam me, after disputing through paypal that his item was wrong and "full of errors". Paypal sided with them even though the picture they posted in the dispute was of that exact item, and I had to pay a dispute fee/pay all the original costs. I called Ebay and they said since the dispute came from Paypal they can't do anything. I called paypal and they couldn't see the case because it wasn't tied to my Paypal account and told me my only option is to pursue legal action in small claims court. The buyer admitted after winning the dispute that the items work but doesn't have the time or money to ship them back, even if I pay for a shipping label. I don't have an option to appeal the dispute, I can't get the chat bot to let them call me again, I can't leave negative feedback on the buyer, who by the way has positive reviews with mentions of never paying and scaming (I only glanced at the fact they had positive reviews before shipping). I'm thinking about just closing my ebay account honestly, but wanted to hear what the community thinks. So far all I've got from people so far is "ebay sucks, that's the cost of selling online these days".
gosimus
Mentor@insulinman14
< Paypal sided with them >
You didn't say it, but I'm concluding that the buyer opened a Not As Described dispute in eBay, which you challenged or otherwise resisted. The buyer probably didn't know that he could click into the case to Ask eBay to Step In, and get an immediate win.
So, the buyer, missing the chance to win in eBay, went to the second level of protection, namely PayPal. As you know, he prevailed there.
You made a mistake. No indictment for that, it's intuitive, and logical, to respond that the NAD claim is false. Unfortunately, logic doesn't apply in these instances. In a NAD claim, eBay always sides with the buyer, if the buyer uses the "step in and help" option.
What you should have done was to accept the return and issue a prepaid return shipping label, wait until the item is in your hands, then issue a refund. A seller's only hold out is to hope the buyer thinks it's too much trouble to box up the item and stand in line at the post office to mail it. If the buyer doesn't send the item back, the case will age closed and the seller doesn't have to refund.
Even if the buyer loses in eBay, he can always start over with PayPal. If that doesn't work either, he can then pursue a chargeback with his credit card company.
insulinman14
OPThat's frustrating. Thanks for the insight.