30d Buyer Returns - Buyers selects “Broken or Defective†then comments: It worked for a week..advise
I sold an antique pocket watch (needs to be wound daily to keep running) and buyer said he’s returning it because it broke after one week of use — he chose “Defective/Damaged†as the reason and Ebay automatically accepted/started the return process. In the comment section the buyer wrote:
—————————————-
Return Reason
Doesn't work or defective
Comments
The watch stopped working one week after it arrived. I took it to a jeweler, and they said that they can t service it due to its age. I was willing to pay for a repair, but now I think I d rather return it. Please advise.
————————————-
What should/can I do? [note this is a 100 year old pocket watch that needs to be wound everyday and can be easily broken by over-winding…ie it’s a delicate old piece of equipment]
jimzgemz
2 comments
lady_madonna
Mentor@jimzgemz
According to the Ebay Money Back Guarantee for buyers, if the buyer filed a Refund Request due to "item doesn't work/defective" then you are obligated to approve the return, provide a prepaid return shipping and refund the buyer when you receive the returned item.
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/managing-returns-refunds/handle-return-request-seller?id=4115
jimzgemz
OPYes — but in his comment on the return request he said IT WORKED FOR ONE WEEK so it wasn’t defective or broken. He chose broken or defective because that was the closet choice to his problem…he used the return request to explain his problem and to ask to be advised on how to proceed saying he was returning it because he didn’t know what else to do…..ebay automatically approved. This is a 100 year old pocket watch that need to be wound everyday — if it worked for a week it clearly worked multiple times and wasn’t broken.