Comics
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Bookmark Share Post
Highlighted

effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

fan1275
Adventurer

Generally, what is the range of potential price increases for golden age, silver and modern comics professionally graded?  For example, how much more might a near mint $2500 1948 comic be worth in theory?

535 Views
Message 1 of 14
13 REPLIES

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Jul 28, 2013 2:46:14 PM
fun_comics9857
Thrill-Seeker
Last Edited 02:47:39 PM

Depends on the comic. Something like Action #1 you're talking 6 figures; while a less important title might not even be affected. 

522 Views
Message 2 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Jul 30, 2013 5:33:58 AM
fan1275
Adventurer

One source has rough estimates for  Golden age comics after professional grading.  Poor to very good: 100% or no change in price.  Fine to very fine: 125%.  VN/NM to mint: 150%.   Does anyone has more information?

480 Views
Message 3 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Jul 30, 2013 7:12:26 AM
fun_comics9857
Thrill-Seeker

comicpriceguide.com has both raw and graded values.

474 Views
Message 4 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Jul 30, 2013 7:53:07 AM
beat_but_complete
Adventurer

fan1275 wrote:

One source has rough estimates for  Golden age comics after professional grading.  Poor to very good: 100% or no change in price.  Fine to very fine: 125%.  VN/NM to mint: 150%.   Does anyone has more information?


Do those percentages include the dealer just adding the grading fees to the price? Any book over $3,000 would cost at least $200 to get slabbed.

468 Views
Message 5 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Jul 30, 2013 7:57:18 AM
beat_but_complete
Adventurer

sun_blaze9857 wrote:

comicpriceguide.com has both raw and graded values.


CPG's values are a joke. TA lot of times they don't use actual data, they use an algorithm to determine prices. They list CGC prices for books that have no slabbed copies in the census, don't exist in the grade stated, and haven't been sold. GPAnalysis would be the best source to determine what percentage over guide a book would sell for slabbed.

467 Views
Message 6 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Jul 31, 2013 6:43:02 AM
fun_comics9857
Thrill-Seeker
Last Edited 06:45:11 AM

One problem with GPAAnalysis is that it's part of CGC and might be biased towards CGC products.

454 Views
Message 7 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Jul 31, 2013 6:47:46 AM
fun_comics9857
Thrill-Seeker

What source has rough estimates for Golden Age comics after professional grading?

451 Views
Message 8 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Jul 31, 2013 8:43:41 AM
beat_but_complete
Adventurer
Last Edited 08:47:01 AM

sun_blaze9857 wrote:

One problem with GPAAnalysis is that it's part of CGC and might be biased towards CGC products.


100% incorrect, completely wrong. GPA has no affiliation with CGC in the manner you speak of. GPA mines data/completed sales of slabbed books and reports them in an objective manner. If they did not, their product would have no value. Plus, it's very easy to verify GPA data against the actual auctions on Ebay, etc.. Where do you get this stuff? Seriously, where?

442 Views
Message 9 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Jul 31, 2013 8:45:07 AM
beat_but_complete
Adventurer
Last Edited 08:49:10 AM

 "What source has rough estimates for Golden Age comics after professional grading?"

 

It's been discussed on the CGC Board many times in the past 11 years.

441 Views
Message 10 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Jul 31, 2013 6:27:04 PM
bpmcomics
Scout
No joke, its like people make up this stuff at random just for the hell of it. GPA owned by CGC... really....?
425 Views
Message 11 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Apr 16, 2014 8:40:02 PM
redxjohn
Enthusiast
Is a PGX or CGC graded...
Say 9.8 wolverine #1 worth more?

Which company is it better to go with?
331 Views
Message 12 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Apr 18, 2014 2:18:45 PM
fun_comics9857
Thrill-Seeker
What do you mean? A PGX grade wouldn't be the same as a CGC grade (if that's what you was asking).

Which company is it better to go with? Do you live in a cave? This question has already been answered so many times. Either way, you would still need to get it appraised. CGC would most likely get you a higher auction price.
313 Views
Message 13 of 14

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

Re: effect of CGC/PGX grading on prices?

in reply to Apr 25, 2014 12:05:31 PM
fun_comics9857
Thrill-Seeker

NM, especially 9.8 CGC could result in a 150 - 200% gain. Anything below VG probably wouldn't affect price, but people would be willing to pay a little more; so all depends on situation and the comic in question. I had done some research and found almost nothing on the PGX grading company. They have a website and you need to submit your books to a P.O. box number. A P.O box number! At least CGC has a physical address. CGC is better known in the collector's society, better with investors, etc. In my opinion, it would be much tougher to make a profit on your PGX graded books. CGC = higher selling price.

286 Views
Message 14 of 14