Archive Selling
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Bookmark Share Post

What kind of feedback do I leave?

What kind of feedback do I leave?

naru_lover
Rising Star

On a different account.  I won something about a week ago.  Seller sent me an invoice that was a few dollars more than the shipping stated in the auction.  Seller explained that I lived further than they expected when they listed the item and the amount in the listing wasn't enough to cover shipping. I wasn't happy about it but I paid. 

 

When I got the package I looked up how much it cost to ship online. (was USPS and Paypal shipping so even with the postage not shown, all the info is on the label to lookup cost at USPS.com)  The original amount posted in the listing was over a dollar more than actual postage and all packageing was recycled.  So they lied about the postage not being enough and cheated a few extra dollars off me. 

 

So now I'm wondering, what should I write in the feedback?  I doubt if I'm allowed to call them a liar... even if they are.

554 Views
Message 1 of 26
25 REPLIES

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 1, 2014 6:40:41 PM
milorocks2014
Trailblazer

You could say they are REALLY bad at math.

 

540 Views
Message 2 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 1, 2014 6:45:24 PM
milorocks2014
Trailblazer

How about 'cahaged shipping fees above and beyond those in listing'.

528 Views
Message 3 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 1, 2014 6:46:27 PM
milorocks2014
Trailblazer

Let me try to thype that again 'charged shipping fees above and beyond those in listing'.

Sorry about that

526 Views
Message 4 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 1, 2014 7:10:51 PM
tripp_the_lab
Rockstar

WHat you should do is ask the seller why they charged you more when the listing covered shipping. DO NOT mention feedback. Maybe they calculated shipping as retail and that's why they thought it would be more. Base your feedback on the response they give, If it is another lie they deserve a neg - "Charged more than listed price for shipping, listed price covered shipping with handling charge"

 

In the future if you pay before the seller sends an invoice they cannot change the ship charge.



You can call me Tony
516 Views
Message 5 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 1, 2014 7:18:51 PM
stinky*felix
Guide

You are allowed to call them a liar, but that will devalue the feedback you leave.

 

Leave a comment that states the facts i.e, Seller increased s/h to 'cover postage' but made $XX in additonal profit instead.


* * * * * * Always act like you are wearing an invisible crown. * * * * * *
507 Views
Message 6 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 1, 2014 8:04:45 PM
naru_lover
Rising Star

Thanks for all the replies and suggestions!  In regards to the invoice, seller sent it right after the auction ended. Like 15 seconds after? (I just checked the time on the emails)  I got the invoice email before I even got the "Enjoy your" email from Ebay.

 

I'm guessing they didn't get as much as they wanted (was an auction item) and so added a few bucks onto shipping.   Something similar has actually happend to me about 5 times in the last 2 years.  I would win a 'free shipping' item and then the seller would send me an invoice with shipping added.   I don't understand why Ebay would allow that.  Sellers are allowed to offer several shipping options when they send out an invoice so Ebay should automatically include the "stated" shipping posted in the listing as one of the options.  (And of course not allow the seller to remove it.)

502 Views
Message 7 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 1, 2014 9:17:35 PM
tonystark74
Guide

miss_my_jake wrote:

Base your feedback on the response they give, If it is another lie they deserve a neg - "Charged more than listed price for shipping, listed price covered shipping with handling charge"


IMO, it doesn't matter why the seller did it, or whether the listed price covered the shipping.  The fact of the matter is that the seller is not allowed to charge more than what was stated in the listing.  They deserve less than positive feedback and 1 star for s/h charges, possibly a 1 for communication as well.

485 Views
Message 8 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 1, 2014 9:18:56 PM
tonystark74
Guide

naru_lover wrote:

Sellers are allowed to offer several shipping options when they send out an invoice so Ebay should automatically include the "stated" shipping posted in the listing as one of the options.  (And of course not allow the seller to remove it.)


Now, that makes way too much sense.  Ebay will never go for it.

484 Views
Message 9 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 1:45:01 AM
Rockstar

tonystark74 wrote:

IMO, it doesn't matter why the seller did it, or whether the listed price covered the shipping.  The fact of the matter is that the seller is not allowed to charge more than what was stated in the listing.  They deserve less than positive feedback and 1 star for s/h charges, possibly a 1 for communication as well.


2 x 1 star...

 

Are the circumstances not important, before you make such a decision?

464 Views
Message 10 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 4:28:44 AM

naru_lover wrote:

Thanks for all the replies and suggestions!  In regards to the invoice, seller sent it right after the auction ended. Actually, this is common with small sellers who don't bother to purchase a scale and "guess" at the weight. 

 Like 15 seconds after? (I just checked the time on the emails)  I got the invoice email before I even got the "Enjoy your" email from Ebay.

 

I'm guessing they didn't get as much as they wanted (was an auction item) and so added a few bucks onto shipping.   Something similar has actually happend to me about 5 times in the last 2 years.  I would win a 'free shipping' item and then the seller would send me an invoice with shipping added.   I don't understand why Ebay would allow that.  Ebay doesn't allow that. However it's up to YOU to know policy and YOUR rights.

 

Sellers are allowed to offer several shipping options when they send out an invoice so Ebay should automatically include the "stated" shipping posted in the listing as one of the options.  (And of course not allow the seller to remove it.) EBay always show postage options -- lowest to highest. The lowest price is the default price. Buyers have to select the upgrade.

 

You NEVER have to pay more than the price stated in the auction.

 

If you want to absolutely crush and destroy the seller for something that you were complicit in, leave a 1 or 2 in shipping / handling charges.

 

If you want to give them a jolt that will hopefully motivate them to learn how to calculate postage more effectively, then leave a 3 or 4.

 

If you are pleased with the actual product, there is no reason to leave anything less than a 5. It was obviously worth a couple more bucks to you, or you wouldn't have paid the extra costs.


454 Views
Message 11 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 1:09:17 PM

Launching off of the prior post .... If I had that experience and it was a great item, exactly as described, and a good total price, I would give 5 stars but mention that the seller charged more for shipping than was advertised in the listing.  Other people bidding on that seller's items will get a heads up and can act appropriately if they bid and win.

415 Views
Message 12 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 4:10:59 PM

Could you please explain why you paid more than the listing price when that is a violation of eBay policy?

 

In fact, could you please explain why you have done so more than once?

 

I'm ever so curious.

390 Views
Message 13 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 4:34:01 PM
Rockstar

freedom4me4ever wrote:

Could you please explain why you paid more than the listing price when that is a violation of eBay policy?

 

In fact, could you please explain why you have done so more than once?

 

I'm ever so curious.


The violation is in the asking.  Not in the paying.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ex Policy Monkey now just another addlepated poster who can't find or explain a gosh darned thing
387 Views
Message 14 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 5:58:16 PM
Last Edited 05:59:36 PM

city*satins wrote:

freedom4me4ever wrote:

Could you please explain why you paid more than the listing price when that is a violation of eBay policy?

 

In fact, could you please explain why you have done so more than once?

 

I'm ever so curious.


The violation is in the asking.  Not in the paying.


Yes...I know. You are absolutely correct!  And it's wrong, and a knowledgeable seller would never do this.

 

But...A knowledgeable buyer would never agree to paying more than the listing price.

 

OP has admitted to overpaying numerous times.

 

So...my question to the OP is...Why?

369 Views
Message 15 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 6:28:43 PM
stinky*felix
Guide

freedom4me4ever wrote:
OP has admitted to overpaying numerous times.

So...my question to the OP is...Why?


My guess would be s/he wanted the item.

And is it really any of our business? 


* * * * * * Always act like you are wearing an invisible crown. * * * * * *
363 Views
Message 16 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 6:42:18 PM
tonystark74
Guide

The other reason would be to avoid getting an unpaid item strike.

359 Views
Message 17 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 9:04:33 PM

stinky*felix wrote:

freedom4me4ever wrote:
OP has admitted to overpaying numerous times.

So...my question to the OP is...Why?


My guess would be s/he wanted the item.

And is it really any of our business? 


Yes it is. Because the OP came to a public forum asking what kind of feedback to leave.

Yes. Because the OP has an admitted history of dealing with sellers who charge more than the stated price.

 

Yes. Because the OP suddenly seems befuddled as to what feedback to leave.

 

Yes. Because the OP doesn't know policy, and / or doesn't care to hold the seller accountable.

 

Yes. Because the buyer wouldn't get an UNPAID ITEM STRIKE as the seller attempted to alter the terms of the sale after the fact.

 

So my questions stands.

 

OP, why do you continue to overpay the invoices for the items that you buy, when policy states that the seller cannot charge you more than is stated in the listing?

 

 

338 Views
Message 18 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 9:54:34 PM
Rockstar
Last Edited 09:57:34 PM

I think I do get your point. The seller committed a violation, but OP (who should also know better) became complicit in the said violation when he paid more than what was stated in the listing. This has happened to him 5 times, so if he didn't bother to know his rights as a buyer, this is what happens....

 

It's just like when buyers make offers on a fixed price listing. It's a policy violation; but if I accepted it, I'd be complicit in violating policy.

326 Views
Message 19 of 26

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

Re: What kind of feedback do I leave?

in reply to Mar 2, 2014 10:17:41 PM
tonystark74
Guide

freedom4me4ever wrote:
Yes. Because the buyer wouldn't get an UNPAID ITEM STRIKE as the seller attempted to alter the terms of the sale after the fact.

Buyers have come to the boards posting about this.  The seller CAN still open an unpaid item case after increasing the shipping price on the invoice.

313 Views
Message 20 of 26